Carcanet Press Logo
Quote of the Day
It is impossible to imagine literary life in Britain without Carcanet.
William Boyd

Review of Valentine Ackland

Frances Bingham, The Guardian, Saturday 20th May, 2006:

Labours of love

Valentine Ackland was a lesbian, a communist, and at one time a Catholic, but above all she was a poet, whose work was overshadowed by controversy


Valentine Ackland, born 100 years ago today, was haunted by the first world war, like so many others of that generation. Too young to fight, yet old enough to witness the carnage, these guilty survivors had a sense of missed opportunity. Valentine's gender, as well as her age, denied her the chance of participation, and heroism always held a complex fascination for her, as did its companion, death.

There were no Ackland sons; Valentine was christened Mary Kathleen, but called Molly by her family. She soon noted social patterns of male privilege and female submission, and began early on to subvert gender expectations by usurping male prerogatives whenever she could. When her father allowed her to drive, shoot and even box, her sister Joan - older by eight years - was insanely jealous, and believed Molly was his favourite. Her revenge on the interloper was to abuse Molly, with psychological torment and physical punishment.

Their father Robert was a pioneer of facial plastic surgery, a deeply troubled man who often took his daughter to visit his hideously disfigured soldier-patients. Ruth, their mother, salved her marital unhappiness with hypochondria and sentimental religion. Brought up in this dark atmosphere of religious hysteria, exaggerated patriotism and psychological violence, Molly became intensely self-conscious, with a heightened awareness of the need for role-playing, whether as crack shot or child saint. She took refuge in the world of books, especially poetry. When her father discovered that she had fallen in love with another schoolgirl, and threatened to disown her, she wrote of her refusal to submit: 'He did not know I had the poets to protect me.' Robert died not long after, still unreconciled with his once-favourite daughter, whose crime he recognised as an indelible part of her character.
Although this first love was forcibly prevented by parental intervention, Molly embarked on another lesbian affair at 17. Bo Foster was older, and able to give Molly the cultural education she lacked. The imaginative, death-obsessed child became a sensitive young woman whose ecstatic delight in the sensual world was heightened by a continual awareness of its transience. Her intense feelings and extreme shyness were disguised by an elaborately courteous, controlled manner; as a debutante she was outwardly only interested in dancing, drinking and driving fast cars.

Although Bo did care for her, she could offer Molly no escape from her unforgiving family. At 19, Molly impulsively married Richard Turpin, a handsome homosexual youth who hoped to overcome the sexuality that made him guilty and miserable. This was, predictably, a disaster; he failed to establish heterosexual credentials, she felt trapped and humiliated. Less than six months later, with the marriage still unconsummated, Molly was persuaded to undergo an operation to remove her hymen for her husband's convenience. This medicalised rape concentrated her mind wonderfully, and she never went back to him again.

Instead, she reinvented herself; Molly Turpin became Valentine Ackland. The process took several years of experimentation, but she declared her independence immediately by putting on trousers. This symbolic act stated that she was more potent than her husband, the gentleman he was not, an independent person, and her father's true heir. She was 'freed into reality' by this sartorial gesture, and the choice of a new name to celebrate her new identity was a similarly profound piece of self-invention. 'Valentine Ackland' was euphonious, androgynous, it sounded like the name of a poet, and invoked the patron saint of love. It erased sad Molly and despairing Mrs Turpin, replacing them with a powerful new persona.

Cross-dressing was a subject of contemporary fascination, and it suited Valentine; she modelled for Eric Gill, Augustus John and Fraulein Reiss (photographer of Dietrich), and had affairs with Dorothy Warren, Nancy Cunard and Anna May Wong, while retaining the long-suffering Bo. In this bohemian company, Valentine discovered the village of Chaldon in Dorset, where an artists' colony had gathered under the eccentric patronage of TF Powys. Here, she began to write poems - often about the place - which sounded with her own individual voice: English, elegiac, strongly felt but elegantly controlled.

Her Chaldon poems resonate with the sound of the sea, the waves of the downs, and the rhythms of the landscape in which the poet is always present. "Space is invisible waves. In leaves of trees / Space-water rustles, and the sway of these / Is only movement of seawater under tide / In restless sway and swing from side to side - / While in the invisible air and in the sky / Spirits like deep-sea fishes are sweeping by /... And the wind is no wind but a fast-flowing current of tide, / And the spirits are blown and driven and cannot abide."

It was in Chaldon that she met Sylvia Townsend Warner, who was enjoying great celebrity as the best-selling author of Lolly Willowes. Sylvia was 12 years older, immensely erudite and talented, with an entirely original cast of mind, and an enormous capacity for love. (Her lover at the time, Percy Buck, was boring her and she found herself admiring Valentine's long legs and cropped hair.) She also admired Valentine's poems, and recognised her as an equal in mind and heart. They fell in love and in 1930 began a passionate affair, which lasted, despite rough weather, until Valentine's death nearly 40 years later.

Before she met Sylvia, Valentine's poetry had been published in literary magazines, and her reputation as a young poet of promise was growing. Her love for Sylvia gave her a new subject of great power, and her work matured. In 1934, they jointly published Whether a Dove or Seagull, the core of which is an exchange of love poems.

The eyes of body, being blindfold
by night
Refer to the eyes of mind - at
brain's command
Study imagination's map, then
order out a hand
To journey forth as deputy for sight.

For many years the fact that the poems are erotic and celebratory, and between women, ensured the book was undiscussed, despite its quality; it is still relatively little known for such a ground-breaking cycle. The poems were unattributed, so that they could be read on merit rather than by author, but this led to confusion, and to Valentine's contribution being undervalued. This unconventional egalitarianism, combined with the subject matter, did the authors' reputations more harm than good at the time.

In the same year, they joined the Communist party. Valentine experimented with writing in a simpler, more muscular style, to suit the coming revolution. This honed her skills further, and she was widely published in the leftwing press. With Sylvia, Valentine volunteered for the British Red Cross in Barcelona during the Spanish civil war, and as delegates to an anti-fascist writers' conference they visited besieged Madrid, and the front lines at Guadalajara. Valentine wrote articles (from 'Our Worker Correspondent') which captured the idealism and chaos of Republican Spain, but this optimistic propaganda contrasts with melancholy poems lamenting the victory of fascism, and her own powerlessness.

A hundred men who came the
road with me
homeward to England out of
fighting Spain
came in mind only; few of them
will see
as I the autumn and the winter rain.

Comrades who stayed behind
will know
a different rain from heaven,
across the mountains weighed
with snow
deadly the storms are driven.

Although she had originally intended to be a combatant in Spain, Valentine was deeply depressed by the reality of war. Her disappointment with the reception of their book, and an increasing intake of alcohol, led her to be unfaithful to Sylvia, who initially tolerated this with wry indulgence, but became worried when an affair with an American fellow-traveller grew serious. Elizabeth Wade White, a wealthy admirer of Sylvia's work, had every intention of supplanting Sylvia; she persuaded them to visit her in America with the hope of detaining Valentine permanently. The outbreak of war interrupted this unhappy situation and Valentine hastily returned to Britain and life with Sylvia.

They moved to Frome Vauchurch, inland from Chaldon, to the house beside the river where they lived for the rest of their lives.

During the war Valentine was effectively imprisoned in Dorset, conscripted for meaningless 'war work' in an army office, but she continued to write poetry about her experience. 'Teaching to Shoot' describes the disturbing proximity of love and death, as she teaches her beloved Sylvia how to kill, in expectation of the Nazi invasion. Valentine assuaged her wartime depression with alcohol and casual affairs, but at the same time she was exploring philosophy and alternative religions, in an attempt to discover a spiritual path.

Perhaps as a result of this, in 1947 her alcoholism suddenly vanished, and never returned. Elizabeth did, however, and after the enforced interval of the war the affair was resumed, much to Sylvia's distress. Part of Valentine's self-justification was that she needed inspiration for her work, but there was no great outpouring of poetry. Instead, after an unhappy ending to the episode, she wrote, 'I feel myself destroyed.' Her poetry did return, and her partnership with Sylvia survived, but she found writing slower and more difficult thereafter.

During the 1950s, she wrote poems about the destruction of the natural world which now seem prophetic, while still celebrating the human relationship to nature with tender lyricism.

While I slept we crossed the line
between May and June:
The morning came, gently walking
down from the hill,
And by the time I stirred it was
full day
And she had brought summer with
her into my room.

At this period her communist affiliations (and lesbian credentials) were a deterrent to many potential publishers - even Sylvia, so much better established, thought her own career had suffered - and although Valentine's poetry continued to appear in literary magazines, she no longer enjoyed the success she'd had in the 30s. Yet she continued to write, recognising it as a necessity for her, and produced some of her best work in this relative obscurity.

The spiritual dimension which sometimes appears as a metaphysical element in her nature poetry reflected Valentine's own quest. In 1956, to Sylvia's dismay, she became a Catholic, though it was a poet's romantic gesture that was not intended as a denial of her leftwing principles. Valentine loved the ritual of the Latin mass, which she perceived as a portal into the spiritual world; she also saw religion as a possible source of creative power. (Once, sexual and poetic potency had seemed synonymous; now the role of priest-poet might bring alternative power and inspiration.) But Catholicism, like other infidelities, did not bring poetic renewal, only intellectual estrangement from Sylvia. In 1968 Valentine finally quit over the modernisation of the church, in particular the use of a vernacular liturgy which she found 'hopelessly unpoetic'. The Quakers provided a sanctuary which Sylvia could also accept.

Poetry of witness was Valentine's other lifelong theme. Speaking for the dispossessed, bearing witness to political injustice, and protesting against war and nuclear weapons, she wrote about Vietnam, Tibet, Soviet dissidents: the human rights issues of her era. Her poem about Hiroshima, 'August 6th 1946', resonates as the 60th anniversary approaches:

When out of a clear sky, the bright
Sky over Japan, they tumbled the
death of light,
For a moment, it's said, there was
brilliance sword-sharp,
A dazzle of white, and then dark.

Into the cavernous blackness, as
home to hell,
Agonies crowded; and high above
in the swell
Of the gentle tide of the sky, lucid
and fair,
Men floated serenely as angels
disporting there.

Her last poems of the 1960s were written in terminal illness; meditations on life, death and the survival of love, they powerfully voice this new inspiration.

When she died of cancer in 1969, Valentine was 63, her bereaved partner 75. Sylvia survived her by almost nine years, and employed her grief editing a posthumous collection of Valentine's poetry, The Nature of the Moment, and preparing their letters for publication. Much of her writing was dedicated to commemorating their life together, and recalling the woman she called 'my light and my gravity'.

Valentine Ackland left a remarkable lifetime's worth of poetry, covering the experience of a singular woman in the mid-20th century. Her poetic voice, lyrical, powerful, melancholy yet life-affirming, surprises by speaking of lesbian love, the socialist struggle, natural beauty, the spiritual world and the evil of war. She achieved heroism of a quiet kind by writing what she believed in, as though it mattered, and as a result her poetry is still vital 100 years after her birth.
To the Valentine Ackland page...
Share this...
The Carcanet Blog Not a Moment Too Soon: Frank Kuppner read more Coco Island: Christine Roseeta Walker read more that which appears: Thomas A Clark read more Come Here to This Gate: Rory Waterman read more Near-Life Experience: Rowland Bagnall read more The Silence: Gillian Clarke read more
Find your local bookshop logo
Arts Council Logo
We thank the Arts Council England for their support and assistance in this interactive Project.
This website ©2000-2024 Carcanet Press Ltd